| Back to Mary Frances Hanline's page
Mary Frances Hanline, Ph.D.
Archived Questions
I am a therapist in a public school. One of
my jobs is to transition the children coming from Early Intervention into our programs.
Our IEP meetings with the EI people and the parents are always a big fight over how much
therapy service is going to be given. The EI program always tells the parents to demand
much more than we think is needed. And to top it off, it's always more than EI has ever
provided. How can I deal with this?
I'm the Early Childhood Coordinator for my
district. Kindergarten comes under each building principal. I want to set up transition
meetings between my staff and the Kindergarten staff, but I'm not getting much cooperation
from the principals. Any suggestions?
I've just come from an IEP meeting
where the team decided that a very small five year old child should stay in pre-school
another year--because he is so small. The parent supports this. I don't think this is
right---shouldn't a child be with his age appropriate peers?
I
am looking for training curriculums for preschools/daycare providers on
inclusion. Also, do you have any suggestions to help with the
transition of children with PDD into a traditional Head Start?
Q. I am a therapist in a public school. One of my jobs is to transition
the children coming from Early Intervention into our programs. Our IEP meetings with the
EI people and the parents are always a big fight over how much therapy service is going to
be given. The EI program always tells the parents to demand much more than we think is
needed. And to top it off, it's always more than EI has ever provided. How can I deal with
this?
A. One of the major concerns that parents have as they and their
children make the transition from an early intervention program to preschool is getting
adequate related services. I would suggest trying the following: 1) Meet with EI personnel
(and parents) and discuss the issue and ways it can be resolved. Perhaps the preschool
program shifts to more of a consultation model than direct service model? If this is the
case, provide information to the EI program about why this is done and give evidence of
the effectiveness of a consultation model? ( ***see below for help with this)
Perhaps you could also provide information about the
preparation classroom teachers get to carry out therapists' recommendations throughout the
child's day. Share information about child development at age 3 and older that would
support less therapy and/or a different model of service delivery. Be willing to
talk about the different criteria for services between the EI and preschool programs. 2)
Invite parents to observe how therapy is delivered in the preschool program so they can
begin to feel more comfortable that their child's therapy program is being implemented
throughout the school day. 3) Encourage parents and EI personnel to talk with parents who
have made the transition and see that their child now receives adequate therapy in the
preschool program. 4) During the initial period of transition,consider providing the
amount of therapy requested by parents, then gradually lessened as the child and family
feel more comfortable in the new environment. This might have to be written into IEPs
and/or additional IEP meetings held to change the therapy.
*** A recent volume of Young Exceptional Children ( 2 (3)) has an
article by Stacy Meece Scott, R.A.McWilliam and Lisa Mayhew "Integrating Therapies
into the Classroom" ( pgs. 15-24) which provides a list of research findings. These
include:
Most parents are unaware of service delivery options.
Initially, parents chose pull-out models, but after two to five years, preferred
integrated models. Children receiving therapy in natural, integrated
contexts fare no worse than children receiving therapy in traditional, segregated ways.
(McWilliams, 1986)
Children who received indirect therapy in the classroom better generalized skills to home
settings than children who received individual pull-out therapy.
(Wilcox, Kouri & Caswell, 1991)
Participants in both individual and group consultation models demonstrated remarkable
increases in both fine and gross motor skills.
( Davies & Gavin, 1994)
Q. I'm the Early Childhood Coordinator for my district. Kindergarten
comes under each building principal. I want to set up transition meetings between my staff
and the Kindergarten staff, but I'm not getting much cooperation from the principals. Any
suggestions?
A. It's hard to respond to
this, not knowing what form the principals' lack of cooperation takes. Is there difficulty
finding time to meet? A place to meet? Getting substitutes if the meetings take place
during the day and teachers have to be relieved from teaching duties? Could the meetings
somehow occur during pre or post planning days for teachers? Could teachers receive some
form of compensation from the Early Childhood program for meeting before or after regular
work hours? Could the Early Childhood program fund substitutes for the Kindergarten
teachers? Are there any teachers or parents that the principals know and respect that
could tactfully discuss the importance of these meetings with the principals? Could you
work to develop a district-wide policy requiring these meetings?
Q. I've just come from an IEP meeting
where the team decided that a very small five year old child should stay in pre-school
another year--because he is so small. The parent supports this. I don't think this is
right---shouldn't a child be with his age appropriate peers?
A. I don't know that size should be a criteria for
remaining in the pre-school program an additional year, but I do think that many children
benefit from that additional year in a preschool program. Is the child likely to be small
in relation to peers her entire life? Perhaps the child could gain some independence or
other skills that would make Kindergarten an easier and less threatening place to be by
remaining in the preschool program another year. I don't know that one year is critical,
especially if the child can move up through the elementary years, etc., with the same
group of children. I support placement with same-age peers, but, even in general
education, there is an increasing tendency to have children without disabilities spend an
extra year in preschool if they have summer birthdays and or seem to need additional time
to mature, so I don't think being six and entering kindergarten is going to be
stigmatizing to the child. In addition, it will be less stigmatizing for the child to do
this at a young age, rather than later in his educational career. I think one of the
beauties of being in early childhood education or early childhood education is that we can
be flexible because of the wide variability in child development. This seems like a time
to support parental wishes and work to make the child's additional year in preschool one
that will truly prepare her for kindergarten. (On a personal note, I plan to have my
daughter do two years of kindergarten at two separate schools because she will be five in
August and I see more advantages to being the oldest in a class than being the youngest.) Q.
I am looking for training curriculums for preschools/daycare providers on
inclusion. Also, do you have any suggestions to help with the
transition of children with PDD into a traditional Head Start? A.
You might try the following curriculums: Mainstreaming
Young Children: A Training Series for Child Care Providers by Patricia W.
Wesley. Frank Porter Graham Child Development Center, University of
North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC Creative Preschool Model,
available from Dr. Pamela Phelps, Creative Preschool, 2746 West Tharpe,
Tallahassee, Florida 32303 To
help with the transition of children with PDD to a traditional Head Start
program, I would suggest some preparation of the staff at the Head Start
before the child(ren) begin(s) to attend. Discussions about supports
that will be available, the needs of the children, etc., would probably be
beneficial. Teachers probably also need to understand about PDD --
what it is, its effects on development, etc. Also, information about
supporting the children's behavior, social skills, and communication
abilities would probably be needed. Teachers at Head Start should
have information about all this BEFORE the child(ren) make the transition. |